There are several roofing materials available for homeowners to choose from. But for most, the debate is mainly between metal roofs and shingles. One of the most popular metals used to make roof panels is steel.
Should you go with a sleek, modern steel roof or stick to the classic charm of shingles? It’s not a one-size-fits-all answer, and the choice depends on your home’s needs, your aesthetic preferences, and your budget.
As a roofing company with years of experience installing both steel roofs and shingles, we understand the dilemma. Let’s break it down so you can make an informed decision.
What Are Steel Roofs And Why Are They Popular?

Steel roofs are known for their exceptional strength and resilience, making them a top choice for homeowners seeking long-lasting protection. Constructed from high-quality metal panels or sheets, steel roofing systems come in a variety of styles, including standing seam panels, corrugated panels, and stone-coated tiles.
Advantages of Steel Roofs
- Longevity: Steel roofs can last for more than 50 years with regular care, far outlasting traditional shingles.
- Durability: These roofs are built to withstand harsh conditions like heavy snow, strong winds, and even fire.
- Energy Efficiency: Steel reflects sunlight, keeping your home cooler in the summer and reducing energy bills.
- Sustainability: Many steel roofs are made from recycled metal and can usually be recycled at the end of their life.
- Low Maintenance: After installation, steel roofs need less upkeep compared to traditional roofing materials.
Challenges of Steel Roofs
- Higher Initial Cost: Steel roofs are more expensive upfront than shingles. In fact, a galvanized steel roof can even cost twice that of asphalt shingles, which can be a dealbreaker if you are on a budget.
- Noise: Rain and hail can be noisier on a metal roof, though this can be minimized with proper insulation.
What Are Asphalt Shingles?

Asphalt shingles are one of the most popular roofing materials in North America, and for good reason. Known for their affordable cost, easy installation process, and versatility, asphalt shingles are a go-to choice for many homeowners. These shingles are made from a base material—usually fiberglass or organic felt—coated with asphalt for waterproofing and topped with mineral granules to add durability and aesthetic appeal.
Advantages of Shingles
- Affordability: Shingles are budget-friendly and one of the most economical roofing materials on the market.
- Variety of Styles: Shingles come in numerous colors, textures, and designs, making it easy to match your home’s aesthetic.
- Simple Installation: The installation process is straightforward, often reducing labor costs and time.
- Widespread Availability: Shingles are readily available, so you won’t face delays waiting for materials.
Challenges of Shingles
- Shorter Lifespan: Depending on the type, shingles typically last 15 to 30 years, significantly less than steel roofs.
- Susceptible to Weather Damage: High winds, heavy rain, and hail can cause shingles to crack, curl, or detach.
- Maintenance Needs: Regular inspections and occasional repairs are necessary to keep shingles in good condition.
Steel Roofs vs. Asphalt Shingles: Types Available
Both steel roofing systems and asphalt shingles have improved a lot over the years and they both come in numerous colors and styles. Here are the types of steel roofs and asphalt shingles:
Types Of Steel Roofs
- Galvanized Steel: Coated with a layer of zinc to prevent rust, galvanized steel is highly durable and corrosion-resistant, making it ideal for areas with heavy rainfall or humidity.
- Galvalume® Steel: A blend of aluminum, zinc, and silicon coatings gives Galvalume steel superior corrosion resistance and heat reflectivity, perfect for energy-efficient roofing solutions.
Types Of Asphalt Shingles
- 3-Tab Shingles: Lightweight and affordable, these shingles are flat and uniform, providing a clean, traditional look. They are ideal for budget-conscious homeowners.
- Architectural Shingles: Also known as dimensional shingles, these offer added thickness and a textured appearance. They’re more durable than 3-tab options.
- Luxury Asphalt Shingles: High-end shingles are designed to replicate the look of premium materials like natural slate or cedar, offering superior durability and aesthetics.
To know more about the types of asphalt shingles, read our detailed guide here.
Steel Roofing Panels vs. Asphalt Shingles: Features
Aside from the features mentioned above, there are other aspects you should consider when choosing between shingles and steel roofs.
Lifespan:
As we already covered, steel roofs can last 50 to 70 years, far outlasting asphalt shingles, which typically last 15 to 30 years.
Wind and Fire Resistance:
Steel roofs excel in wind and fire resistance, easily handling extreme conditions. Asphalt shingles, specifically architectural and luxury shingles, come with good wind warranties (some offering wind protection up to 160 mph). However, in general, asphalt shingles are more susceptible to damage from high winds or fire.
Mold and Maintenance:
While steel roofs are inherently resistant to mold and mildew growth, several asphalt shingles, such as shingles manufactured by Atlas, come with algae-resistant properties. However, this is generally available in architectural or luxury options, not 3-tabs.
Aesthetic Appeal:
Shingles are versatile, offering a wide range of colors and textures to complement traditional or modern homes. Steel roofs, while slightly more limited in design, can provide a clean, contemporary look that stands out. Stone-coated steel options mimic the appearance of shingles or tiles, combining the best of both worlds.
Steel Roofing Panels vs. Asphalt Shingles: Cost
Your budget plays a major role when choosing a roofing material. Both steel roofs and asphalt shingles differ greatly in terms of cost. Steel roofs have a higher upfront cost but lower long-term maintenance expenses. Depending on the type, a steel roof can cost anywhere from $5 to $15 per square foot.
Shingles, on the other hand, are easier on the wallet initially, costing in the range of $3 to $8 per square foot. But you may need to replace them sooner. Think about whether you’re prioritizing short-term savings or long-term value.
How Much Does A Steel Roof Cost? (per square foot) | How Much Do Shingle Roofs Cost? (per square foot) |
Galvalume Steel Roofs: $5 to $9 | Traditional (3-tab): $2 to $3 |
Galvanized: $6 to $17 | Architectural: $4 to $8 |
When Should You Choose Steel Roofs vs. Shingles?
There’s no universal answer, but here are some general guidelines:
- Steel Roofs Are Ideal If: You value durability, live in a harsh climate, or plan to stay in your home for a long time.
- Shingles Are Better If: You’re on a tight budget, prefer a specific aesthetic, or need a quick, cost-effective solution.
Still unsure? Our team is here to help you weigh your options and find the perfect fit for your home.
Conclusion: The Right Roof for You
Choosing between steel roofs and shingles can feel overwhelming, but it doesn’t have to be. Both materials have their strengths and challenges, and the best choice ultimately depends on your unique situation.
At Prestige Roofing LLC, we’re experts in both shingles and steel roofs. Whether you’re looking for a sleek, durable steel roof or a classic, cost-effective shingle roof, we’ve got you covered.
Contact us today at (920) 791-0414 to schedule a consultation or get a personalized quote. Let’s build the roof that’s just right for your home.