When you’re planning to replace your roof, you’ll likely find yourself choosing between two popular options: metal roofs and traditional shingles. Let’s explore both choices to help you make the best decision for your home.
Understanding Metal Roofs
Your home deserves the best protection, and metal roofing systems have become increasingly popular among homeowners. Metal roofs are available in materials like steel, aluminum, copper, or zinc. They come in various styles, from standing seam panels to metal shingles that mimic the look of traditional roofing materials.
Advantages of Metal Roofs
When you choose a metal roof, you’re investing in durability that’s hard to match. These roofs can last 40-70 years with proper maintenance, making them a long-term solution for your home. Your energy bills might also thank you, as metal roofs reflect sunlight and can reduce cooling costs by 10-25%.
Metal roofs are incredibly strong and can withstand harsh weather conditions. You won’t have to worry about strong winds and heavy snow slides right off the slick surface. They’re also fire-resistant, which adds an extra layer of protection to your home.
Limitations of Metal Roofs
While metal roofs offer many benefits, they do come with some drawbacks. The initial cost might make you think twice – metal roofs can cost 2-3 times more than traditional shingles. During heavy rain or hail, metal roofs can be noiser than other materials, though proper insulation can help minimize this issue.
All About Shingles (Asphalt Shingles)
Asphalt shingles have been the go-to roofing choice for American homes for decades. This roofing material is made from a fiberglass base coated with asphalt and mineral granules.
Benefits of Choosing Shingles
Your budget might appreciate asphalt shingles more, as they’re typically the more affordable option. Installation costs are lower, and most roofing contractors are experienced with this material. You’ll find shingles in countless colors and styles, making it easy to match your home’s aesthetic.
Repairs are usually straightforward and cost-effective – if a section gets damaged, you can often replace just the affected shingles rather than large sections of the roof.
Limitations of Shingles
Shingles’ lifespan is shorter than that of metal roofs, typically lasting 15-30 years, depending on your climate and maintenance. They’re more vulnerable to strong winds and can crack in extreme temperature changes. During hot summers, dark-colored shingles might absorb heat and increase your cooling costs.
Direct Comparison: Metal vs. Shingle Roofs
There is a lot to think about when planning a roof replacement. Here are some factors to consider when choosing between a metal roof and a shingle roof.
Cost
Your investment in either roofing option varies depending on your location and home size. Metal roofs typically cost $4 to $30 per square foot, while asphalt shingles range from $3 to $7 per square foot. However, metal roofs’ longer lifespan might offset the higher initial cost.
Durability and Maintenance
With metal roofs, you’ll spend less time on maintenance. They resist moss and algae growth, and simple annual inspections are usually sufficient to keep them in good shape. Plus, your metal roof won’t crack, curl, or lose granules like shingles do.
Shingles require more regular maintenance, including cleaning gutters of loose granules and checking for curled or damaged sections. You might need to clean off moss or algae growth more frequently, especially in humid climates.
Environmental Impact
If you’re environmentally conscious, metal roofs offer several green benefits. They’re often made from recycled materials and are 100% recyclable at the end of their life. Metal roofs can also serve as an excellent base for solar panels if you’re considering renewable energy.
Asphalt shingles, while improving in eco-friendliness, still contribute significantly to construction waste. However, some manufacturers like CertainTeed and Malarkey have impressive recycling initiatives for shingles.
Metal Roof vs. Shingles: An Overview
| Difference | Metal Roof | Shingles |
| Material Types | Galvanized/stainless steel, aluminum, zinc, copper | Fiberglass base, layers of asphalt and granules |
| Durability | The average lifespan of a metal roofing system is 40-70 years. Metals like copper can survive up to 100 years. | The average durability of a shingles roofing system can be 25-35 years. |
| Cost estimate for 1,500 square foot roof | $7,500 – $ 24,000 | $6,000 – $20,000 |
Additional Factors to Consider Before Deciding
Choosing the right material for your roof is the most important factor while planning for an installation, and these are some more factors you should consider before it happens.
Climate
Climatic conditions play an important part in choosing the right material for your roof. If you live in an area with extreme weather, metal roofs might be worth the investment due to their ability to withstand severe conditions. But if you live in a moderate climate, a shingle roof is a better option.
Budget
Budget is another factor to consider while looking for a roofing upgrade. Metal roofs cost $120 to $900 per square (100 square feet), while asphalt shingles are more budget-friendly at $70 to $150 per square. When making your decision, consider both upfront costs and long-term value, including potential energy savings and maintenance expenses.
House Design
Different home styles pair naturally with specific roofing materials to enhance their architectural beauty. Victorian and craftsman homes often shine with traditional shingles, while modern and contemporary designs complement metal roofs’ sleek appearance. Consider your home’s architectural character and local aesthetic when choosing your roofing material to maintain its authentic charm and curb appeal.
Local Building Codes
Before starting your roofing project, check your local homeowners association and building codes carefully. Some neighborhoods have strict guidelines about roofing materials, colors, and styles. Homeowners associations may restrict metal roofs to preserve a cohesive community look, while others might require specific shingle grades. Always secure necessary approvals to avoid costly modifications later.
Energy Efficiency
Metal roofs excel at energy efficiency by reflecting sunlight and reducing cooling costs by up to 25%. Their superior insulation properties help maintain consistent indoor temperatures year-round, lowering your energy bills. Unlike traditional shingles that absorb heat, metal roofs’ reflective surfaces make them an ideal choice for homeowners focused on energy conservation and sustainability.
Remember that both options have proven track records of protecting homes. Your choice should align with your specific needs, budget, and long-term plans for your home.
Conclusion
Whether you choose the durability and longevity of metal or the traditional appeal and affordability of shingles, your new roof will play a crucial role in protecting your home for years to come. Take time to weigh your options and make the choice that best suits your unique circumstances.
For help understanding your options, call Prestige Roofing at (920) 791-0414. A member of our team will evaluate your specific situation and provide personalized recommendations for your roof replacement.