From Minor Repairs To Major Replacement

Tailored Solutions For Northern Wisconsin's Weather Challenges

Transparent, Friendly, And Hassle-Free Service

From Minor Repairs To Major Replacement

From Serving Our Country
to Serving Your Roof

Get Instant Quote call (920) 791-0414

Pros & Cons Of DIY Roof Replacement (& How Much It Costs)

Posted on March 4, 2024

Pros & Cons Of DIY Roof Replacement (& How Much It Costs)

When it comes to replacing your roof, you may debate between doing it yourself or hiring professionals. A roof replacement is a huge home improvement project that helps improve the aesthetics and value of your property, and with the DIY trend, many homeowners think of taking it on themselves. While DIY roof replacement might save you some money, weighing the pros and cons is crucial. In this blog post, we’ll explore both sides of professional and DIY roof replacement to help you decide. 

What Are The Pros And Cons Of DIY Roof Replacement?

Pros of DIY Roof Replacement

1. Cost Savings

The obvious benefit of doing your own roof replacement is saving money. Compared to hiring a professional roofing contractor, a DIY roof replacement project can result in significant cost savings. By avoiding the costs related to labor, you can direct your budget toward purchasing other supplies and equipment for the project.

2. Flexibility and Control

When you replace your roof yourself, you have complete control over the materials used for the project. You can set your own hours and pace, and have total control over the project schedule. DIY roof replacement is also a great way to pick up new abilities and important construction and roofing knowledge.

Cons Of DIY Roof Replacement

1. Lack of Expertise

It takes expertise, experience, and accuracy to perform roofing tasks correctly. It is more likely that mistakes will be made during the replacement process if you do not have a professional roofer’s expertise. These mistakes can lead to expensive future repairs due to leaks, structural damage, or improper ventilation.

2. Quality Concerns

Professional roofers have the knowledge and resources needed to guarantee excellent work and durable outcomes. On the other hand, if you replace your roof yourself, the quality might be poor since you won’t have the necessary knowledge or equipment. Poorly installed roof replacements can cause problems like leaks, insufficient insulation, or early deterioration.

3. Safety Risks

As falls are a common cause of injuries and fatalities in the construction industry, working on roofs is naturally risky. DIY roof replacement can put your health at serious risk if you don’t have the right safety gear, training, or precautions. When contemplating a roof replacement, safety must come first.

4. Warranty Protection

Skilled roofers frequently offer guarantees on the materials and craftsmanship they utilize. Should there be problems or defects after installation, these warranties provide financial security and peace of mind. You will forfeit these warranties if you choose to replace your roof yourself, and you will be entirely liable for any potential future repairs or replacements.

5. Legal Compliance

Permits to building codes and regulations may be necessary for roofing projects. DIYers run the risk of paying fines or having to redo subpar work if they are unaware of these legal requirements.

6. Insurance Implications

If damage results from careless work or poor installation, replacing your roof yourself could invalidate your homeowner’s insurance.

7. Resale Value Impact

A poorly executed DIY roof replacement could lower the resale value of your home if potential buyers perceive it as substandard workmanship that may require corrections.

Cost Analysis: DIY Roof Replacement vs. Professional Roof Replacement

DIY Roof Replacement

You might be tempted to DIY your roof replacement in an attempt to save costs. However, DIY projects frequently include risks and hidden costs. The average cost of a DIY roof replacement is between $2,500 and $5,000. Although the initial expenses for supplies, equipment, and licenses might appear lower, there is a genuine risk of costly errors and personal injury. 

On the other hand, while professional roof replacement may initially cost more, it’s important to appreciate the knowledge, craftsmanship, and long-term benefits it offers. These contractors are skilled in selecting and installing the appropriate materials, which ensures a long lasting, well-built roof.

The cost of a professional roof replacement in Wisconsin varies based on factors like roof size, pitch, location, and material. Here’s a summary:

1. Roof Size: Larger roofs require more time and materials, leading to a more expensive total. 

2. Roof Pitch: Steeper roofs generally mean higher labor costs.

3. Location: Urban areas usually cost more due to higher living expenses.

4. Material Costs: Prices per square foot vary:

MATERIAL AVERAGE COST
Asphalt Shingles$4.25
Wood Shingles$6
Metal Shingles$7.50
Standing Seam Metal Panels$10
Clay Tiles$10
Slate Tiles$15
Copper Tiles$20

5. Labor Costs: Typically range from $50 to $100 per hour.

6. Additional Costs: Include removal of old materials, decking repair, and new flashing or gutters.

Overall, a professionally installed roof can cost between $5,700 to $12,500 on average, with the typical cost of around $10,000.

What Are The Warranties Offered For DIY Roof Replacement Compared To Professional Replacement?

When deciding whether to replace your roof yourself or hire a professional, there are important differences to consider. Professional roofers generally offer warranties for their work, ensuring they’ll fix any issues later on at no extra cost. Additionally, some roofing material manufacturers only honor warranties if professionals install their products. Doing it yourself could void these material warranties from the manufacturer and lead to more problems. Professional roofers also carry insurance, so if anything goes wrong during the project, you won’t be stuck with unexpected expenses. 

While opting for a DIY approach might save you money upfront and give you the freedom to customize, it’s riskier and might not result in a job well done. On the other hand, hiring a professional may cost more initially, but you benefit from their expertise, safety measures, and the assurance that the job is done correctly and backed by a warranty.

How To Choose The Right Roofing Contractor If You Decide To Hire A Professional

To pick the right roofing expert when hiring a professional, follow these steps:

1. Check Online and Reviews:

  • Start by searching online and reading Google reviews of local roofing professionals to learn about their reputations and customer satisfaction levels.
  • Focus on reviews from the last 3-6 months for recent experiences, and explore additional sources like the Better Business Bureau for more insights.

2. Choose Local Contractors:

  • Give priority to local roofing professionals. This ensures they adhere to local regulations, have proper paperwork, and are easily reachable if problems arise.

3. Review Credentials and Insurance:

  • Verify the contractor’s credentials, including licenses and insurance coverage like liability and workers’ compensation.

4. Ask for References and Past Projects:

  • Request a list of references and past clients to speak to about their satisfaction with the contractor’s previous work on their roofs.

5. Get Detailed Quotes:

  • Get a written contract or detailed breakdown outlining project specifics such as duration, materials, safety measures, payment terms, cleanup procedures, and warranty details.

A reputable roofing company like Prestige Roofing will prioritize customer satisfaction by offering both a solid workmanship warranty and a reliable manufacturer warranty. The workmanship warranty covers the labor for roof installations, while the manufacturer warranty protects the materials used. We use top-quality materials backed by a 50-year limited lifetime warranty from trusted manufacturers. Our experienced team follows building codes, resolves issues promptly, and maintains transparent communication throughout the entire process.

Looking For Professional Roof Replacement Services? We Have Got You Covered!

Homeowners should consider both the advantages and disadvantages of DIY roof replacement before beginning. Saving money and having a sense of accomplishment are undoubtedly benefits, but the work is labor intensive and requires careful attention to detail. Prioritizing safety above all else is important, after all roofing is a serious undertaking. Therefore, make sure you’re choosing what’s best for you and your house, whether you choose to do it yourself or hire professionals.

Get in touch with Prestige Roofing if you’re thinking about seeking professional assistance. Our team of roofers is well-versed in professional roof replacement services and is capable of handling the task with care and skill. Make sure your roof receives the high-quality care it needs by choosing us for your roof replacement. For the best roofing services, give us a call at (920) 791-0414.