Do you want to install a metal roof? It’s a great option! Over the last few years, metal roofs have become a popular choice for roofing. Many homeowners choose them over traditional shingles for their durability and longer lifespan.
But when you start your research, you will find that metal roofs come in different types. Two of the most common types of metal roofs that are often debated are standing seam panels and corrugated panels.
Both have their fair share in the industry and have unique features. But which one should you install? Today, we will compare standing seam vs. corrugated metal roofs.
What Is A Standing Seam Metal Roof?
A standing seam metal roof is a type of roof that features long, vertical panels running from the top of your roof down to the eaves. The panels interlock with each other via raised seams (hence the name “standing seam”). These seams are a few inches above the flat part of the panel, giving your roof a sleek, clean look.
One of the major differences that separates standing seam panels from other types of metal roofs is how it is fastened to the roof deck. The fasteners—the screws or nails holding the panels in place—are hidden beneath the seams. This feature not only makes the roof look smoother but also protects the fasteners from the weather, reducing the chances of leaks or rust over time. Since the fasteners are concealed and the panels lock together tightly, standing seam roofs are excellent at handling harsh weather.
Advantages Of Standing Seam Metal Roofing System
If you install a standing seam metal roof, you get several advantages. Here are some of them:
Excellent Longevity
One of the biggest selling points of this roof is its longevity. Standing seam metal roofs can last anywhere from 40 to 70 years, sometimes even longer, with proper maintenance.
Better Protection Against Leaks
Because the fasteners are hidden and the seams are raised, there’s less chance for water to seep into the roof. This makes standing seam roofs excellent for rainy or snowy regions. They’re also incredibly wind-resistant.
Low Maintenance
Standing seam roofs don’t require a lot of upkeep. You won’t need to worry about rusted screws, and because the metal panels are designed to expand and contract with temperature changes, there’s less risk of cracking or warping. However, annual inspections will be required.
Want to know more? Visit our guide: Decoding Why Standing Seam Metal Roof Installation Is The Best Option For Your Home
Limitations Of Standing Seam Metal Roofing Systems
Are there problems you should be aware of? Yes. Here are some issues you need to consider:
Higher Cost
One of the biggest downsides to standing seam metal roofs is the price. They’re generally more expensive than corrugated metal roofs, both in terms of materials and installation.
Complex Installation
Installing a standing seam roof requires more expertise than other types of metal roofs. Because the panels interlock and the fasteners are hidden, the process can be more labor-intensive.
What Is a Corrugated Metal Roof?
Now, let’s move on to the competition. A corrugated metal roof is made of sheets of metal that have a wavy, or “corrugated,” pattern.
Those waves or ridges are what give the roof its strength. The sheets are usually installed with visible fasteners—screws that go right through the metal and into the roof deck beneath. Unlike standing seam roofs, where the fasteners are hidden, these are easy to spot. This gives corrugated roofs a more industrial or rustic look, which can be a great fit depending on the style of your home or building.
Benefits Of Installing Corrugated Metal Roofs
Corrugated metal roofs, though not as popular, do offer some good benefits.
Affordability
One of the biggest reasons homeowners opt for corrugated metal roofs is the price. They’re generally much more affordable than standing seam roofs, both in terms of material costs and installation.
Ease of Installation
Corrugated metal roofs are easier and faster to install, which can save you time and money. The sheets can cover larger areas of your roof at once, and because the fasteners are exposed, they’re much simpler to attach.
Good Durability for the Price
While standing seam roofs are known for their superior durability, don’t underestimate corrugated metal. These roofs can still hold up well against rain, snow, and wind.
Limitations Of Corrugated Roofing Systems
Visible Fasteners Can Lead to Leaks
One of the main downsides of corrugated metal roofs is that the fasteners are exposed. Over time, the screws can loosen or the gaskets around them can wear out, leading to potential leaks.
Higher Maintenance
As mentioned, the exposed fasteners can be a maintenance headache over time. You’ll need to periodically check the roof for loose screws or worn-out washers to prevent leaks. While the roof itself is durable, the maintenance factor could be a drawback for some homeowners.
Standing Seam vs. Corrugated Metal: What’s Right for You?
Now that you have a clear idea of what standing seam and corrugated metal roofs are all about, let’s break it down even further. In this section, we’ll go over some crucial parameters and compare both these metal roofing panels.
Budget Considerations
Standing seam metal roof installation is more expensive than a corrugated metal roof. On average you will find that standing seam roofing costs almost double what you will pay for the latter. This is because the system is more durable and requires professional labor which adds to the cost.
Talking about specifics, the cost of standing seam metal roofs is around $24,000 to $40,000. On the other hand, corrugated roofing replacement will cost in the range of $10,000 to $22,000.
Style Preferences
Style is another crucial thing that you should consider before you choose the right metal roof. For a modern home, especially in an urban or suburban setting, a standing seam roof offers a sleek, polished appearance that blends well with contemporary architecture. In fact, there is a wide variety of standing seam metal roof colors that can further raise curb appeal.
On the other hand, if your home has a rustic, farmhouse, or industrial style, a corrugated metal roof could be the perfect complement.
Longevity and Weather Concerns
Standing seam roofs are your best bet if you live in an area prone to heavy rain, snow, or strong winds, such as Northeastern Wisconsin. The hidden fasteners and interlocking panels provide excellent protection against leaks and wear. These metal roof panels also generally have Class 4 wind resistance.
In contrast, corrugated roofs can still handle tough weather but require a bit more vigilance when it comes to maintaining fasteners and checking for potential leaks.
Temperature Changes
Metal roofs usually excel in all departments, but there are a few concerns to be aware of. One of them is facing naturally occurring temperature changes. In this regard, standing seam metal roofs are more adaptable. Standing seam roofs manage this well due to their concealed fasteners, which allow the panels to move slightly without causing damage or leaks.
However, over time, temperature fluctuations can cause the fasteners of both options to loosen, which may lead to leaks or wear if not maintained.
Energy Efficiency
Metal roofs, in general, are known for being energy-efficient, reflecting sunlight, and keeping homes cooler in warmer months. Standing seam roofs tend to excel in this department because of their seamless design, which helps to better insulate your home. They also make a great base for solar panels if you’re considering going green. Corrugated metal is also energy-efficient, but not as much as its counterpart.
Here is an overview of the differences between standing seam and corrugated metal roofs:
Factor | Standing Seam | Corrugated Metal |
Budget | Higher upfront cost (materials + installation) | More affordable, ideal for tighter budgets |
Fastener System | Hidden fastener system | Exposed fastener system |
Style | Modern, sleek, minimalist look | Rustic, industrial, classic aesthetic |
Durability | Lasts 40-70 years, minimal maintenance required | Lasts 40-50 years, more maintenance required |
Weather Resistance | Excellent protection against leaks, wind, snow | Good protection but fasteners can loosen |
Installation Complexity | Requires skilled professional installers | Easier and faster to install |
Location Suitability | Best for homes in harsh weather areas | Ideal for barns, rural homes, and sheds |
Conclusion
We hope that with this comparison of standing seam vs. corrugated metal roofs, you will be able to make an informed decision as to which option is best for your property.
As you can see, both standing seam and corrugated roofing systems have their own pros and cons. It all depends on your budget and personal preference.
If you have made a decision, it’s time to move to the next step and hire the team of Prestige Roofing LLC for your metal roof installation. We are Northeastern Wisconsin’s best roofing company. We have years of experience in standing seam metal roof installation.
If you are still stuck, don’t worry. Contact us today at (920) 791-0414 and we will be happy to assist you.